The 3 on the left weren't in sealed bag. They just been in the box forever. The other 2 I opened the bag the other day and put the vial on the cards. And I think but can't promise, these where like early 90's fragrances? ?
I haven't had any issues myself. Some people say when the perfumes like this they smell like alcohol. But don't all of them at 1st wiff?? All I smell is perfume..lol...and the lipsticks, haven't had much issue. Certain ones are definitely not good when older. But you can SEE right off. And some people collect the items for nostalgia
Guess I just have strong nose then. On any perfume avon or not, I have to smell twice to smell the perfume. I don't smell straight up alcohol, just a hint with any. And this is strictly straight from the bottle too. Like if I put in on 1st I don't have to smell twice.